- Published on Thursday, 01 November 2012 11:56
This is part four of our three part series on how to negotiate with Chinese companies. Yes, you read it right. Part four of three. How To Handle Chinese Negotiating Tactics, part one is here, part two is here, and part three is here. We originally planned a three part series, but when a reader alerted me to a post by Andrew Hupert on how American negotiators are viewed by their Chinese counterparts, I could not resist piling on a part four. So here goes.
In Hupert’s post, entitled American Negotiating Culture – Through the Eyes of the Chinese Counterparty, Hupert writes on how Chinese companies see their American negotiating counterparts. Hupert has taught Chinese negotiating tactics at NYU’s Business School, conducted extensive research on the subject, and recently wrote a book on it, entitled,The Fragile Bridge: Conflict Management in Chinese Business. In other words, when it comes to negotiating with Chinese companies, he knows whereof he speaks. And his speaking says that how Chinese companies view American companies will influences negotiations between them. So if American companies can better understand their own negotiating tendencies, and more importantly, how their negotiating tendencies play out to a Chinese audience, they can better handle negotiating with Chinese companies.
Hupert’s article sets out the “American cultural quirks” with which Chinese companies have to deal when negotiating. Remember that the below is how Chinese companies view American negotiating tactics; it does not mean that their views are accurate.
- “First and foremost – we are the only negotiating culture that leads with the lawyers. Europeans consider negotiation to be an exercise in diplomacy while Asians consider it the province of paternalistic company leaders to build lasting relationships. American negotiators – even when they are salesmen or purchasing managers – are fixated on contracts and legal institutions (like courts and regulations). Whereas traditional Asian negotiators feel that relationships are the key to business and contracts are merely written records of agreements between individuals, Americans put more weight on the document than on the human bonds between business leaders.” We wrote about this in The Lawyer’s Role In China Business Transactions.
- We are the only negotiating culture that believes that liability can be assigned in advance through a contract. This is one of the many aspects of international negotiation that has become “normal,” but it still strikes traditional Asian negotiators as crazy that Americans consider contracts binding even as the market environment changes. Asian negotiators in general, and Chinese in particular, feel that as the external situation evolves, so must a business relationship. Many Chinese partners have been bewildered and disappointed when their American partner stated waving a piece of paper in their face instead of responding fairly and maturely to new market realities.
- Americans believe that negotiations end. To Chinese, the negotiation is part-and-parcel of the business relationship. As long as the counterparties are still engaged in business, the negotiation is supposed to continue. What’s the point of taking the time to build a connection if you aren’t going to grow the relationship through continuous give and take?
- Americans want to decide everything in advance and put procedures ahead of human decisions. Chinese (and most other Asian) negotiators understand that conflict and differences of opinion are inevitable, and their business agreements usually assume that the leaders or concerned parties from each side will work things out informally. American contracts, with their penalty clauses and rigid requirements, are not only insulting and arbitrary, but seem designed to undermine any kind of positive relationship.
- Americans love deadlines, timetables and schedules, even when there is no business rationale for them. They can be arbitrary and illogical.
- Most disturbing of all, American negotiators are adversarial and rude. We insist on running everything and taking control of situations that we don’t understand. We are famous for coming to China and trying to sell inappropriate products or services at ridiculous prices. Our technology and designs are nice enough, but we expect people to pay over and over for the same thing – even after their people have figured out how to make the same thing.
According to Hupert, American companies should at least recognize that Chinese companies are “struggling just as hard as you are to successfully manage the yawning gap between your cultures.” Okay….
What do you think?
Dan Harris is founder of the Harris & Moure law firm, a boutique international law firm focusing on small and medium sized businesses that operate internationally. China is the fastest growing area for the firm. Dan writes ChinaLawBlog.com as a source of China legal and business information.